Jewelry Appraisal and Buying Services

With decades of experience, Mayflower Estate Buyers is your trusted partner for jewelry appraisals, sales, and consignments. Whether you’re settling an estate or looking to sell your jewelry, we provide transparent, expert guidance to ensure a smooth and rewarding experience.

sample appraisal report

Professional Jewelry Appraisal Services

We offer professional appraisals for insurance, estate planning, divorce settlements, resale, and more. Each report is tailored to meet your specific needs with accuracy and care.

Insurance Appraisals

Ensure you’re properly protected with our detailed jewelry appraisal for insurance.

gemologist inspecting a loose diamond

Fair Market Appraisals

Understand the current value of your jewelry for resale, liquidation, or personal knowledge with a fair market appraisal.

gemologist sorting diamonds

Estate Appraisals

Navigate estate planning and settlements confidently with accurate estate appraisals tailored to your needs.

gemologist weighing a loose gemstone
art deco sapphire ring
carved gemstone earrings
antique ruby and diamond brooch

Types of Jewelry We Appraise

At Mayflower Estate Buyers, we appraise a wide range of jewelry and collectibles, providing you with the expert opinion you need to make informed decisions:

why are jewelry appraisals important
Amanda Coleman-Phelps Mayflower Estate Buyers

Amanda Coleman-Phelps

Appraiser

Nicholle Mogavero Mayflower Estate Buyers

Nicholle Mogavero​

Appraiser & Lead Buyer​

a photo of gemologist-appraiser Randy Lightfoot

Randy Lightfoot​

Gemologist-Appraiser​

Peggy Coleman

Appraiser & Buyer

What to Expect from a Jewelry Appraisal

At Mayflower Estate Buyers, our client-centric appraisal process ensures your comfort and clarity. We begin with a discussion of your appraisal needs, followed by a thorough inspection of your jewelry to provide an accurate and legally compliant report.

Get to Know Our Expert Appraisers

With over 40 years of combined experience, our dedicated team includes Graduate Gemologists from GIA, Senior Gemologists accredited by AGA, and more. As certified members of professional appraisal and gemological organizations, as well as Registered Gemologist Appraisers, we are committed to providing you with unparalleled expertise and service.

pearl earring appraisal

Convenient and Secure Jewelry Buying Process

At Mayflower Estate Buyers, we provide a seamless experience for selling or consigning your jewelry. Our expert team is dedicated to ensuring you receive the best value for your pieces while guiding you through every step of the process.

Types of Jewelry We Purchase

Gold Jewelry
We are interested in all types of gold jewelry, including rings, necklaces, bracelets, earrings, and more. This includes gold of all colors (yellow, white, and rose) and purities (karats).

Antique and Vintage Jewelry
We appreciate the unique character and craftsmanship of antique and vintage jewelry. Bring your pieces in for an evaluation.

Diamond Jewelry
Let us assess the value of your diamond jewelry, including engagement rings, wedding bands, and other diamond pieces.

we buy gemstone jewelry

Designer Jewelry
Do you have designer jewelry from brands like Tiffany & Co., Cartier, or Rolex? We are interested in purchasing these pieces.

Fine Watches
We are interested in purchasing a wide variety of luxury timepieces from well-known brands. Whether you have a cherished heirloom or a pre-owned watch you no longer wear, we can offer a competitive price.

Silver
We buy all types of silver jewelry and collectibles, including rings, necklaces, bracelets, and more. Our competitive prices are based on weight and current market value, ensuring you receive a fair offer for your pieces.

Consign Your Jewelry

When you choose to consign your jewelry with Mayflower, you benefit from our unique trunk show events held at independent jewelry stores across the country. This approach allows your pieces to reach a wider audience of collectors, maximizing exposure and enhancing the potential value of your jewelry. Our dedicated team ensures that your items are showcased beautifully, creating an inviting atmosphere for buyers. Experience the art of consignment with us and discover how we can help elevate your jewelry’s worth.

consign your jewelry
professional jewelry appraisal services

Our Simple Buying and Consignment Process

1. Schedule a Free Consultation
Book an appointment online or give us a call to discuss your jewelry. We’ll provide expert guidance on selling or consigning your pieces.

2. Free Evaluation
Bring your jewelry in for a no-obligation evaluation. We’ll assess your items and provide insights based on our expertise.

3. Transparent Offer
After evaluating your jewelry, we’ll present you with a fair, competitive offer based on current market trends and our detailed assessment.

Frequently Asked Questions About Jewelry Consignment

We accept a wide variety of jewelry, including gold, diamond, antique, designer pieces, and more. If you’re unsure whether your item qualifies, feel free to reach out for guidance.

When you consign with us, your jewelry is showcased at our trunk shows, allowing it to be seen by a larger audience of collectors. Once sold, you receive a portion of the sale price, maximizing your potential return.

The consignment process typically requires time to connect with potential buyers. While it may not be immediate, our trunk shows allow for greater exposure, leading to potentially higher sale prices.

Yes, if your jewelry does not sell during the consignment period, you can arrange to have it returned to you at no additional charge.

Absolutely. We prioritize the security and safety of all jewelry entrusted to us and take extensive measures to protect your items during the consignment process.

What types of jewelry can I consign?
We accept a wide variety of jewelry, including gold, diamond, antique, designer pieces, and more. If you’re unsure whether your item qualifies, feel free to reach out for guidance.

How does the consignment process work?
When you consign with us, your jewelry is showcased at our trunk shows, allowing it to be seen by a larger audience of collectors. Once sold, you receive a portion of the sale price, maximizing your potential return.

How long does the consignment process take?
The consignment process typically requires time to connect with potential buyers. While it may not be immediate, our trunk shows allow for greater exposure, leading to potentially higher sale prices.

Can I get my jewelry back if it doesn’t sell?
Yes, if your jewelry does not sell during the consignment period, you can arrange to have it returned to you at no additional charge.

Is my jewelry safe while in your possession?
Absolutely. We prioritize the security and safety of all jewelry entrusted to us and take extensive measures to protect your items during the consignment process.

Why Choose Mayflower?

Expertise You Can Trust
Our certified appraisers bring over 40 years of combined experience to every jewelry evaluation.

Personalized Service
We prioritize building a relationship with you, tailoring our approach to meet your unique needs.

Commitment to Integrity
We maintain high ethical standards, ensuring honest appraisals and transparent processes.

Comprehensive Support
Whether you’re looking to sell, consign, or simply learn more about your jewelry, we’re dedicated to assisting you.

Skip to content