Meet Our Team
Unmatched Experience and Qualifications
At Mayflower Estate Buyers, our dedicated team combines over 40 years of experience with the most esteemed credentials in the jewelry industry. We are proud to be Graduate Gemologists from GIA, Senior Gemologists accredited by AGA, and members of the National Association of Jewelry Appraisers. Our expertise is further enhanced by our certifications as Registered Gemologist Appraisers from the International School of Gemology and our roles as Jewelry Forensic Specialists. Additionally, we contribute to leading organizations such as the American Gem Society, Leading Jewelers Guild, and Maryland Retail Association, while being active members of ASA and The Society of Jewelry Historians
Our Team
Amanda Coleman-Phelps
Owner & Appraiser
Amanda’s expertise in appraising a wide range of jewelry allows her to provide clients with accurate and trustworthy valuations. Her attention to detail ensures that each appraisal reflects the true value of cherished items.
Nicholle Mogavero
Appraiser & Lead Buyer
Nicholle brings her extensive knowledge and passion for jewelry to Mayflower, specializing in appraisals and purchasing. She believes in the power of stories behind each piece and is dedicated to helping clients preserve their legacies.
Randy Lightfoot
Gemologist-Appraiser
With a keen eye for detail and a commitment to excellence, Randy is a valued gemologist-appraiser at Mayflower. He combines his technical skills with a deep appreciation for the art of jewelry to deliver exceptional evaluations.
Peggy Coleman
Appraiser & Buyer
Peggy specializes in appraisals and purchasing, leveraging her expertise to assist clients in understanding the value of their jewelry. Her commitment to quality and client satisfaction makes her an invaluable member of our team.
Mayflower Estate Buyers: Your One-Stop Destination
At Mayflower Estate Buyers, we pride ourselves on our trusted expertise, exceptional service, and unwavering dedication to preserving the stories and value of your treasured jewelry. We look forward to the privilege of serving you.