How to Get Your Estate Jewelry Appraised

Estate jewelry – a captivating blend of vintage elegance and timeless style. These pieces, often passed down through generations, hold sentimental value that transcends their monetary worth. But whether you’re considering selling, insuring, or simply curious about their worth, getting your estate jewelry appraised is a crucial step. Here’s a guide to navigate the appraisal process for your treasured heirlooms:

Finding the Right Appraiser

Expertise Matters

Don’t settle for just any appraiser. Seek out a professional with a proven track record in appraising estate jewelry. Look for affiliations with organizations like the  National Association of Jewelry Appraisers (NAJA). These organizations ensure members adhere to strict ethical standards and maintain a high level of expertise.

Experience is Key

An appraiser who specializes in estate jewelry will have a deeper understanding of vintage styles, materials, and market trends specific to these pieces. This ensures a more accurate and informed evaluation.

Preparing for the Appraisal

Gather Information: Do you have any documentation related to the jewelry’s history, such as receipts, certificates, or family records? This information can be invaluable to the appraiser in determining authenticity, age, and potential provenance.

Cleanliness is Key: While a deep clean might not be necessary, presenting your jewelry in a clean and well-maintained state allows the appraiser to get a clearer picture of its condition.

Ask Questions: Don’t hesitate to ask questions during the appraisal process! Understanding the appraiser’s methodology and the factors influencing value will empower you to make informed decisions about your jewelry.

The Appraisal Process

Detailed Examination: The appraiser will meticulously examine your jewelry, assessing the materials (metals, gemstones), craftsmanship, hallmarks (if any), and overall condition.


Market Research: The appraiser will research the current market for similar estate jewelry pieces. This might involve auction records, online retailers specializing in estate jewelry, and industry publications.


The Appraisal Report: Following the examination and research, you’ll receive a formal appraisal report detailing the description of your jewelry, material breakdown, estimated value for your purpose (replacement value, fair market value), and any relevant background information.

Getting your estate jewelry appraised unlocks its hidden story and empowers you to make informed decisions about its future. By following these steps and working with a qualified appraiser, you can ensure your treasured pieces are valued accurately and respectfully.

Ready to uncover the value of your jewelry?

Mayflower’s team of  appraisers possesses a wealth of experience in evaluating estate pieces. We understand the sentimental importance of these heirlooms and are committed to providing accurate and professional appraisals. Schedule an appointment with Mayflower today and embark on a journey of discovery with your estate jewelry!

Safeguard Your Valuables: Schedule Your Jewelry Appraisal Today!

Skip to content