Choosing a Qualified Jewelry Appraiser:
What to Look For

Jewelry holds immense sentimental and financial value. When it comes time for an appraisal, entrusting your precious pieces to the right professional is crucial. But with so many options available, how do you ensure you’re choosing a qualified jewelry appraiser?


This guide will equip you with the knowledge to confidently navigate the process and select the most suitable appraiser for your needs.

a jewelry appraiser taking notes in a notepad in preparation for creating a jewelry appraisal for estate purposes

Qualifications and Certification

Look for appraisers with designations like Graduate Gemologist (G.G.) from the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) or equivalent qualifications. These programs provide in-depth knowledge of gemstone identification, grading, and jewelry appraisal methods.

Understanding Memberships

While not essential, memberships in organizations like the National Association of Jewelry Appraisers (NAJA) and the American Gem Society (AGS) demonstrate the appraiser’s dedication to continuing education and staying informed about industry updates. These associations also uphold ethical standards and offer resources to members.

Vetting and Choosing the Right Appraiser

Review Credentials and Experience

Scrutinize the appraiser’s CV, checking for relevant qualifications, certifications, and experience in appraising jewelry similar to yours.

Seek Recommendations

Talk to your attorney, financial advisor, or friends and family for recommendations. They may have experience working with appraisers and offer valuable insights.

Schedule Consultations

Contact potential appraisers to discuss your needs and ask questions about their appraisal process, fees, and turnaround times. This allows you to gauge their professionalism and communication style.

Verify References and Insurance

Don’t hesitate to request references and contact past clients to get their feedback on the appraiser’s service and expertise. Ensure the appraiser has adequate professional liability insurance to protect you in case of any issues.

What to Bring to the Appraisal Appointment

The jewelry itself

You’ll need the piece(s) for evaluation.

Documentation

If you have any paperwork related to its purchase, provenance, or previous appraisals, bring it along.

Your questions

Prepare a list of questions about the appraisal process, fees, or anything else on your mind.

Red Flags to Watch Out For

Unreasonably low fees

Be wary of prices significantly below market rates. A proper appraisal takes time and expertise.

Pressure to sell

A reputable appraiser shouldn’t pressure you to sell your jewelry. Their focus is on valuation, not sales.

Lack of willingness to answer questions

A qualified appraiser should be open to explaining their process and answering your inquiries.

By following these steps and prioritizing qualifications, affiliations, and clear communication, you can confidently select a jewelry appraiser who will provide a professional, unbiased evaluation of your treasured pieces. Remember, a qualified appraisal protects your jewelry’s value, whether for insurance purposes, estate planning, or simply understanding its worth. Don’t hesitate to invest the time in finding the right appraiser – your jewelry deserves it.

Safeguard Your Valuables: Schedule Your Jewelry Appraisal Today!

Skip to content